, Newburyport, MA


January 23, 2014

The Manning dilemma

Rooting for MVP QB might not be a bad idea

To root for Peyton Manning or not to root for Peyton Manning, that is the question.

Prince Hamlet has nothing on several million New Englanders.

Talk about a dilemma, sort of like the New York Yankees in the 2001 postseason, after the Sept. 11 terrorist bombings. Searching deep into the ventricles of your heart for a soft spot for ... gulp! ... the enemy (of course I mean “sports” enemy).

You could take the anti-Seattle Seahawks (or anti-Richard Sherman) approach. The combination of cocky, brash and talkative usually is very easy to root against.

But this is different. This result, rooting for Manning and the Denver Broncos, has ramifications.

The Tom-Brady-Is-The-Greatest argument we’ve heard and said around here so often might not be true.

We must admit that Manning’s resume, with two Super Bowls and five MVP Awards, is comparable to Brady’s three Super Bowls and two MVPs.

An argument could be made either way without a true winner ever being declared.

Or, New Englanders could take a more mature, empathic approach, rooting for what seems to be a great young man who has overcome incredible odds and injury to return to the top.

Let’s be honest, few people thought Manning had this season — 55 TDs, 10 int., 13 wins and a Super Bowl berth — in him after having bones fused in his neck, especially at his age.

But you have to hand it to him. Manning actually had the best season of his career on a new team at age 37 and a pair of 13-3 seasons after the potentially career-ending surgery.

While we hate to admit that we enjoyed seeing the whiny-arms-in-the-air guy from several years ago, with Patriots like Rodney Harrison and Tedy Bruschi confusing and confouding the future Hall of Famer, Manning has perservered.

Text Only | Photo Reprints

NDN Video
How Will Wiggins Deal Impact Potential Love Trade? Tony Dungy Weighs in on Michael Sam Dareus fails conditioning test, Watkins lifts spirits Clay Travis On Mettenberger Punch & "Dumbest Fanbase" - @TheBuzzeronFOX Bowlsby talks cheating in NCAA Kluwe: How can Tony Dungy advocate felons, not Michael Sam SNC Minute: Phils lose; Lee set to return Eagles less than a week away from training camp Could Cliff Lee's health affect trade value? McCarthy and Stairs break down the Phillies' loss 105-year-old woman throws first pitch McIlroy wins British Open, Tiger finishes 69th Astros, Aiken fail to reach deal Could Rousey beat Mayweather? Can the Panthers replace Steve Smith? Will Bengals sign Dalton to long-term deal? Offseason Report: Biggest Question Marks in the AFC West Ole Miss facing increased expectations Derek Jeter Respect Ad Delivers Larry’s Notebook: Is Jimmie Johnson Behind the Curve?
Special Features